New Owner of an original survivor (1974 3.0 CSA with only 35k miles)

Should I replace the transmission(manual) and bumpers while I own it and replace when ready to sell?


  • Total voters
    19

kwyjibo

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
737
Reaction score
152
Location
Denver, Colorado
Welcome Greg
Glad to see another coupe in the area. Except for the recent road closures, my drives often take me through Evergreen. Let me know if ever want to join in
 

HB Chris

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
19,418
Reaction score
8,759
Location
Huntington Beach, CA
5EBA11B3-D813-49F1-A528-349D1045C18F.png
 
Messages
20
Reaction score
8
If it had 135,000 miles and needed to be restored, I'd say go for both conversions, if that's what you wanted to do.

However, since it's in such fine condition, despite my preference for manual transmissions, I recommend keeping it as is. It's only original once.

I am not offended by the diving board bumpers, as so many people seem to be. Perhaps that is because my 1975 3.0Si escaped major body damage twice thanks to the large bumpers. Sure, they're not integrated into the original design, but they do the job they're intended to do. Retrofitting to an early bumper design is not just a matter of sourcing parts and bolting them on, and the idea of changing back to original is probably a non-starter.

Your call.
 

Drew Gregg

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
1,576
Reaction score
1,211
Location
Ft. Lauderdale
Greg--Welcome to the forum. A conversion to a 5 speed,chrome bumper car will be expensive and will keep the car in a garage/shop for some time. I suggest you contact the BMW coupe specialists to get a time and dollar estimate for the conversion. Korman Autoworks (NC), VSR (NH) LaJolla Independent (CA) and CoupeKing (CA).
You will find their info here in the Forum. You can then determine if this conversion meets your expectations. And you'll get to know what NLA (no longer available) means when searching for all of the parts needed to complete your project.
PS--Your tires look like Michelin XAS. I strongly suggest you check how old they are before any serious driving.
 

Sooner

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $
Messages
889
Reaction score
169
Location
Farmington, NM
Used to live in Genesee, but no coupe then, what fun that would have been, now just around SW Colorado,
 

Gregs3point0

Member
Messages
24
Reaction score
10
Location
Evergreen, CO
Welcome Greg
Glad to see another coupe in the area. Except for the recent road closures, my drives often take me through Evergreen. Let me know if ever want to join in
Would really enjoy getting together for a drive. Perhaps the next time the roads are dry and clear of sand. Thanks for reaching out and feel free to call me at 303-949-2319 anytime to discuss our cars or getting together for a drive. Please return the favor on your contact info as well. Greg
 

Gregs3point0

Member
Messages
24
Reaction score
10
Location
Evergreen, CO
Hi Gregs3point0,
I also have a ‘74 with big bumpers and automatic. I love it just the way it is. You should sort it out well so you can drive it anywhere at any time, fix any cosmetics that bother you, and see if you love your car just the way it is too. If I ever decide I want a small bumper 5-speed for a more sporting experience I will sell this one intact and buy another that’s already configured that way. Welcome! Post more pictures.
I agree Eric. I respect the car for what it is and the fact that it is a survivor. It should remain the same and preserved in the original configuration. Owning this car has made me appreciate this era of BMW even more. Perhaps I will buy another and have it as more of a project car than a preservation exercise. Thanks for your feedback. More pictures to come.
 

Ski coach

Deceased
Site Donor $
Messages
298
Reaction score
107
Location
Durham, NH
Don’t touch it! You’ll start down a slippery slope to “improve” it, and before you know it, you’ll have lost all it’s wonderful individuallty.
 

Ohmess

I wanna DRIVE!
Site Donor $
Messages
4,896
Reaction score
2,721
Location
Aiken, SC
You describe both the bumpers and the automatic as irritating, which pretty much answers the question. Here in the US, neither the 5 speed swap nor the change to smaller bumpers detracts from the value of the car.

Having swapped my automatic for a 5 speed, I very much prefer this particular change. The five speed is lighter, which makes the car feel a little faster, and driving with a stick is a more engaging driving experience.

I happen to dislike the US bumpers on our cars. I also agree with the comment posted earlier that BMW designed the car for the smaller bumpers, and that the US mandated changes denigrated a very nice design. On the other hand, the bumper change for your car is a more difficult question, given how nice your car looks.

I would plan to do the five speed conversion, and spend some more time thinking about your bumpers. After you attend some events and compare your car to others, it will come to you.
 

teahead

aka "Rob"
Site Donor $
Messages
6,393
Reaction score
1,848
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
Remove the front bumper and put on a CSL air dam. CHeaper in the short-term.

Remove the rear bumper and get the holes (including rear side marker) welded up and get the necessary pre-73 brackets and bumper parts.

The $2-3k you spend will do wonders. And drive the automatic around for awhile. 5-speed project can be done next year. Ditto a front bumper.
 

Peter Coomaraswamy

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
3,787
Reaction score
896
Location
Austin, TX
844 coupes received the large bumpers out of 30,565 in total, maybe 700 of those were Hoffman deliveries to the US. Although rare, no one is ever going to reinstall these in the future so if you change them out there is no need to keep them. I would keep it just as it is, you have a true survivor. Same with the auto, it makes no sense to keep it if you go to a five speed which I would recommend.
I (and my car) fall into the category of "quite modified" but yours is so original and perfect I would have to leave it as is. Completely unmolested cars have a certain "presence" that even a slightly modified version does not have.

Alternatively, if you decide that you want to modify an e9 to suite your taste you could buy a beat up one and bring her back to life :)
 

Gregs3point0

Member
Messages
24
Reaction score
10
Location
Evergreen, CO
I (and my car) fall into the category of "quite modified" but yours is so original and perfect I would have to leave it as is. Completely unmolested cars have a certain "presence" that even a slightly modified version does not have.

Alternatively, if you decide that you want to modify an e9 to suite your taste you could buy a beat up one and bring her back to life :)
Peter - I totally agree with your perspective. As soon as I put this car in my garage I realized that she's not going to be much fun relative to the "tinker factor". I respect the fact that she is in somewhat perfect condition with an all original state. My goal is to share/show this vehicle and allow all the BMW enthusiasts to enjoy....and hopefully pass it down to my children so they can do the same. I am not sure how many true survivors of the E9 are really out there ....but I feel kinda feel lucky to have this one...despite being an automatic, no sunroof and big bumpers!
As far as a restomod is concerned....I have dreams of taking an less desireable E9 and really having fun restoring it and making it more of a fun driver. The people converting these to a 3.0CSE is quite interesting as the maintenance factor goes away (for the most part). I am a purist at heart and shifting through the gears is something that has always been something I really enjoy. Anyhow - thanks again for sharing your perspective.
 

Peter Coomaraswamy

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
3,787
Reaction score
896
Location
Austin, TX
I have a feeling that there are not too many undiscovered e9's out there; from what I have experienced- for what it's worth- there are 4 main categories of e9's available now "original"- truly original, "driving modified e9's-(all states of condition)", "non driving but rebuild-able examples", and those with "vegetation growing through the floors and sunroofs"- or yard art.... It's the second and third group that offer us the most personal expression and in my opinion the most fun, but there's nothing wrong with a true time capsule!! :)...again this is just my opinion and may not reflect the views of this station-
 

Ohmess

I wanna DRIVE!
Site Donor $
Messages
4,896
Reaction score
2,721
Location
Aiken, SC
Gregspoint0 - do not despair the lack of a sunroof. Sunroof cars often had more rust because of clogged drains. I did not want a sunroof car when I searched for mine.
 

teahead

aka "Rob"
Site Donor $
Messages
6,393
Reaction score
1,848
Location
Tacoma, WA, USA
Not sure if you want to take on an E9 restoration; serious rabbit hole.

I would just modify your's. 5-speed is easy to change w/o cutting and welding.
 

jman

New Member
Messages
7
Reaction score
4
Location
dallas, TX
Greg, If it aint broke don't fix it, modifying cars is fun but when you can start with a low mile car leave it alone IMO and enjoy.

If you just want a BMW project I can get you a great deal on a 528 in Denver that needs a full rebuild.
I grew up in Evergreen and still have a few contacts in the area.
 

Stan

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
7,008
Reaction score
1,526
Location
Newmarket, New Hampshire
Peter - I totally agree with your perspective. As soon as I put this car in my garage I realized that she's not going to be much fun relative to the "tinker factor". I respect the fact that she is in somewhat perfect condition with an all original state. My goal is to share/show this vehicle and allow all the BMW enthusiasts to enjoy....and hopefully pass it down to my children so they can do the same. I am not sure how many true survivors of the E9 are really out there ....but I feel kinda feel lucky to have this one...despite being an automatic, no sunroof and big bumpers!
As far as a restomod is concerned....I have dreams of taking an less desireable E9 and really having fun restoring it and making it more of a fun driver. The people converting these to a 3.0CSE is quite interesting as the maintenance factor goes away (for the most part). I am a purist at heart and shifting through the gears is something that has always been something I really enjoy. Anyhow - thanks again for sharing your perspective.
If you can keep th survivor as is and get another to "restored" then I would advise keeping the current coupe unmolested.
If you are not getting a second coupe, I would change the bumpers and transmission. People will not notice that change and it will improve the car.
 
Top