What's it worth.... or.... What would you do?????

bavbob

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
3,354
Reaction score
1,569
Location
Boston, Ma
Go over the car, see big ticket items that need to be dealt with and price them out, then remember for every big ticket item you see, there are 2 that you don't see..
 

CSteve

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
3,767
Reaction score
1,279
Location
Bucks County, PA
Go over the car, see big ticket items that need to be dealt with and price them out, then remember for every big ticket item you see, there are 2 that you don't see..
And add a 20% pad to the price of everything.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
It looks very promising to me. My guess is that most of the patina will wash or lightly sand off. I don’t see rust on the bumpers or on the inner fenders. In the shot that includes the dash end, I don’t see water damage.

I would ask to open it up. Blow off all the leaves in the engine bay.

Check:
The floor pans
Rocker edge (can’t see most of it)
Above glove box
above fuse box
under rear seats (they pull straight up)
trunk well
rear shock towers (feel with your hand or stick your cell in there)

Report back. I would offer $8K and talk about how it needs thousands to be even a driver. Don’t go past $15K if you are looking for a budget starting point. Keep in mind that a car in better shape may be cheaper in the long run contingent upon your restoration skills.

My seller’s girlfriend was using BHCC as a comp. If thing go that way assure him that those cars don’t represent the true market value of rusty e9’s.
Thanks Markos!
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Thanks, I will pass that on to him.

Barry and Chris, when you both say, "you will be...., or I replaced" do you mean YOU, the owner operator with the skills and tools to do all this, or do you mean an experienced mechanic? And body and paint work, the black hole of our coupes? Wtinker, do you have any or all of these skills? Or a trust fund. Or a good job with Microsoft?

Steve
Steve, skills... well I guess better than most but not as good as some. Trust fund...... nope, missed that boat. Self employed so not quite as good as a MS job.

We do have a space, a lift, (2) 2002's, (2) E21's and a '88 E28 M5.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Sorry for delayed reply. As stated below, I've got more experience than most but not as much as some. 5 pre 1990 BMWs in the family at this point. Not to afraid of anything mechanical. Got to friends on the painting.
 

JayWltrs

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $
Messages
954
Reaction score
534
Location
Oklahoma City
You might go through some of the prior restoration projects and see what you're up against on the things noted before. But you seem game and to have a lot of experience. I wonder if the owners would let you evict the Clampetts' dinner, put in a new battery, add a little oil, get a clean gas container and line with a new filter on it up to the pump and see if it starts--unless you can see the electrical has been eaten away. I only say this because a number of things in the engine bay look like they were once well maintained--radiator fins look perfect, coolant hoses, A/C bits, wiper motor, distributor, etc. look better than some running cars recently for sale, and the air cover has less rust than many. All of this is superficial, but I'm kind of astonished at how hearty these things are and even a neophyte like me can get them running. I also take some heart in the newer battery that it was running just before parked.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
You might go through some of the prior restoration projects and see what you're up against on the things noted before. But you seem game and to have a lot of experience. I wonder if the owners would let you evict the Clampetts' dinner, put in a new battery, add a little oil, get a clean gas container and line with a new filter on it up to the pump and see if it starts--unless you can see the electrical has been eaten away. I only say this because a number of things in the engine bay look like they were once well maintained--radiator fins look perfect, coolant hoses, A/C bits, wiper motor, distributor, etc. look better than some running cars recently for sale, and the air cover has less rust than many. All of this is superficial, but I'm kind of astonished at how hearty these things are and even a neophyte like me can get them running. I also take some heart in the newer battery that it was running just before parked.
Jay, thanks for the thoughts and comments. They duplicate mine. Based on how clean the engine bay is ( critters excluded) ... I think it will start w/o to much effort but then is it worth more to the owner....... such is the delema of life!
 

Rek

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,113
Reaction score
351
Location
Islington London England
You can look at this on a cost benefit analysis and it probably won't work for you, but thats not what its all about.

What do you WANT to do? Can you picture it as a solid runner which you can use each day? You'll get extraordinary help and expertise on this forum from the members which simplifies the whole thing. You can also do it all in stages and if you're handy mechanically, then these can be very rewarding.

I jumped for mine which was worse that yours, albeit cheaper - but I thought with my heart and not my head. I vowed that I would do the minimum to get it on the road until my budget could afford it.

Finally - how is the relationship with your wife? Prepare for that to be tested :)
 

JayWltrs

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $
Messages
954
Reaction score
534
Location
Oklahoma City
Jay, thanks for the thoughts and comments. They duplicate mine. Based on how clean the engine bay is ( critters excluded) ... I think it will start w/o to much effort but then is it worth more to the owner....... such is the delema of life!

Good thought. If it is in an estate and been sitting there long enough to birth the moss and weeds (not to mention a marsupial), you'd think they'd just want to unload it at this point. Of course, I shouldn't presume people are reasonable, and lots of crazy goes on in some estates. That might explain why it hasn't been sold already.
 

Stan

Well-Known Member
Site Donor $$
Messages
6,997
Reaction score
1,526
Location
Newmarket, New Hampshire
Agreed if you pick the carcass clean like I am. I still have quite a ways to go. I wouldn’t part this car. It looks too nice!
I picked a carcass pretty clean a few years ago. It was fun, I had some help and most importantly, a place where the car was stored that was not in my garage where my wife would see it daily for 2 years
 

JFENG

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
3,177
Reaction score
1,393
Location
Bahston (Boston)
First, your pictures are all of the unimportant areas. If you've been lurking here, you know the pictures we all want to see to make an initial guess about condition of the body. But from what you've shared, it might not be too rusty.

How capable of a mechanic are you? Have you ever rebuilt a complete brake system and are you comfortable pulling a motor, disassembling, working with a machine shop and assembling yourself? Do you know how to use tie-rod separators, spring compressors, flare wrenches, a DVM, hog ring pliers, tubing bender & flaring tool, spade crimper, and tap and die? Do you have a decent enclosed workspace and tools for this sort of thing? If yes I think this car looks like a great candidate for your goal of getting an E9 on the road for well under $20k. As others have mentioned, you should assume as the minimum a full end-to-end rebuild of the entire hydraulic (including the transmission), fuel, cooling systems, and a partial restoration of the electrical system. If the motor is seized then you get to have fun with your big tools and precision measuring devices.

I'd call it a $4k car.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
First, your pictures are all of the unimportant areas. If you've been lurking here, you know the pictures we all want to see to make an initial guess about condition of the body. But from what you've shared, it might not be too rusty.

How capable of a mechanic are you? Have you ever rebuilt a complete brake system and are you comfortable pulling a motor, disassembling, working with a machine shop and assembling yourself? Do you know how to use tie-rod separators, spring compressors, flare wrenches, a DVM, hog ring pliers, tubing bender & flaring tool, spade crimper, and tap and die? Do you have a decent enclosed workspace and tools for this sort of thing? If yes I think this car looks like a great candidate for your goal of getting an E9 on the road for well under $20k. As others have mentioned, you should assume as the minimum a full end-to-end rebuild of the entire hydraulic (including the transmission), fuel, cooling systems, and a partial restoration of the electrical system. If the motor is seized then you get to have fun with your big tools and precision measuring devices.

I'd call it a $4k car.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Agreed the pics are superficial. That was as far as I could go without permission.

As far as capability, my son and I have done the stem to stern described above on my 2002, his E28 M5, his 320i etc.
On mine, this included complete engine rebuild and 5-speed swap.

As far a shop, we are set with everything needed, including lift.

Thanks for the positive nod. We will just have to wait and see what they want for it.
 

wtinker

Member
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Good thought. If it is in an estate and been sitting there long enough to birth the moss and weeds (not to mention a marsupial), you'd think they'd just want to unload it at this point. Of course, I shouldn't presume people are reasonable, and lots of crazy goes on in some estates. That might explain why it hasn't been sold already.
Agreed. It's rumored that the guy to assume ownership doesn't want it. Time will tell.......
 

rsporsche

Moderator
Site Donor $$
Messages
10,640
Reaction score
3,671
Location
Atlanta, GA
Wil, i think many people have outlined the potential body costs and where to look for hidden rust. i can tell you if you had a car with zero rust, a complete repaint is 10k to 15k if you do a lot of the removal / reinstall. the problem on the outside is the parts that continue to go NLA. for instance - front grilles, rocker trim, many other trims, windshield gaskets (you can buy aftermarket), switches, etc.

here is where you will have difficulty controlling costs - while you have the engine out - lets replace it (14k +/-), lets replace this system with new, that system, etc. that can easily be another 10k. can you do it for less - maybe ... it depends on what you are starting with. if you start with a running / driving car ... you can keep it going for a lot less. a car that isn't running, doesn't have a good cooling system or brakes ... the costs can be substantial.

my opinion, save and buy a decent, running car ... you will save money. then restore it at a later date. the other side is, its not hard to take 2 years+ to get a car from this shape to a decent driver
 

Markos

Well-Known Member
Site Donor
Messages
13,369
Reaction score
7,502
Location
Seattle, WA
Agreed the pics are superficial. That was as far as I could go without permission.

As far as capability, my son and I have done the stem to stern described above on my 2002, his E28 M5, his 320i etc.
On mine, this included complete engine rebuild and 5-speed swap.

As far a shop, we are set with everything needed, including lift.

Thanks for the positive nod. We will just have to wait and see what they want for it.

You already know my thoughts but I’ll state publicly that you are a perfect candidate for this car and it would be a missed opportunity to pass it up.
 
Top